Top Five
A feature of this site will be the Top Five list. Some of you who have played fantasy sports with me know of my infatuation with the top five list. In honor of the Cubs/Sox series this weekend I will showcase my top five Cubs and Sox players of all time. First the Cubs. Let me say this was tough. Do you allow players who retired before the turn of the century? Do you pick players who were really really good for a short period of time or do you reward longevity? I pretty much allowed everything and I think it makes a pretty good list.
1. Cap Anson-The real Mr. Cub. Played with them forever. Leads all Cubs in hits, runs, RBI, with a .329 avg and less AB's than Banks. Problems: Retired in 1897. Played in a segregated league. Played before Wrigley (where did they play?)
2. Ernie Banks- Second best career numbers. Played in the modern era but not the juiced ball era. Most well known spokesmen for the team. Problems: Played on crappy teams. Only hit .274 lifetime.
3. Sammy Sosa-Maybe has the best numbers if you look at how few AB's he had compared to the rest of em. Problems: Roids?
4. Hack Wilson- Forget Sammy this guy was a stud. Had less than a third of Sosa's AB's but more than half as many RBI's. Same with hits. Had almost as many runs as Sosa again with less than a third of the AB's. He hit about 370 RBI's in the 1929 and 1930 seasons. That wasn't that long ago but still they were playing in a segregated league.
5.Mordecai Brown- It was very hard to leave Billy Williams off the list but this guy was great and I had to put a pitcher up there. He was 188-86 with a 1.80 ERA. Pretty nice. Yes he did pitch a long time ago but at least it was in the 1900's. I mean I coulda went with Larry Corcoran who threw 250 complete games in a five season span. Man whoever had him on their fantasy team in 1880 was making bank!
Stay tuned for the Sox list.

3 Comments:
Mac, Sosa's numbers are better than Sandberg, Santo's, and even William's. Not only that but he had like 2000 less AB's than them. So really his number's dwarf theirs. Williams only hit 12 points higher than Sosa. Santo I believe was a few points lower. He got big hits too he carried that '98 team on his back and I remember some nice homers in the 03 playoffs. I know people are bitter about Sosa right now, time will tell what his legacy will be. Kevin I saw there was a Sutclife on the team in like the 1890's so which one are you talking about?
2:51 PM
Nate... like the site. And Mac that was a long post wow.
8:52 AM
Mac, Mac, Mac, as much as I wanna let this one die I just can't. For you to label Sosa as simply a "good home run guy" is an extreme understatement. He didn't simply get more homeruns than Sandberg he DOUBLED the amount of homers Sandberg had. You are comparing apples and oranges. Its like comparing Hank Aaron to Andres Gallaraga. Sosa may have more strike outs, but he also has more walks, total bases, better on base percentage and way better slugging. Not to mention that Sosa and McGwire saved baseball with their homerun race. Forget about Sandberg. Sosa had a five or six season effort that has never been matched in the history of baseball.
9:08 AM
Post a Comment
<< Home